The Great Detective is an online reasoning roundtable game similar to Werewolf. So who is the murderer in the trial of The Great Detective's Night Talk S? Many netizens are interested. Let’s take a look at the analysis of the trial of Chat Night Talk S.
Act One: Liu Tianbao is not himself at this time. There are four conflict points:
1. It is mentioned in Fan Tingzang's script that Liu Tianbao was invited by the police station to give many speeches after he was sent to jail. It is impossible for a person with a stutter to give speeches.
2. And Li Jingbao's script mentioned that his existence was discovered when he and Liu Tianbao met for the first time, and they were mutual enemies, so it is impossible to say that there is no S at all.
3. In the butler's script, I once saw a man with an injured right arm who looked like Liu Tiankang entering the villa and not responding to greetings. The hand that carved the word "天" was healed the next day, which obviously proved that the two were not the same person.
4. Yu Zebei's script mentioned that Liu Tianyu signed with his left hand, indicating that he was left-handed, but the person he saw was holding the candlestick high with his right hand, which is obviously problematic.
To sum up, Liu Tianbao at this time is not himself.
The tire was punctured by the housekeeper Wu Kun. There were no problems with the two people's tires on the way here, so it could only have been punctured after the two arrived at the villa. Therefore, the only people who can puncture the tires may be the housekeepers Wu Kun and Fan Tingsui who are out to pick up guests. Fan Lingsui was in a car accident, and he didn't have the tools to destroy the tires, and he had no motive, so he could be eliminated quickly. Even if we can't rule it out, we can still find from clues that there are black particles on the butler's gloves, which can directly identify him as the person who destroyed everyone's tires.
The person who forged the will was Yu Zebei.
First of all, the fake will was placed on the second floor, so the person who forged the will had to go to the second floor. The only people who went to the second floor were the housekeeper, Liu Feizi, and Yu Zebei. Let’s first look at the housekeeper Wu Kun. The real will is for him to receive the inheritance. He has no motive or reason to do such a thing. Secondly, there is Liu Feiyu. The purpose of letting the housekeeper destroy the will is to pretend to be his brother and directly receive the family property. The will The premise is that the person is dead, so for him, a living person standing here making a fake will is simply superfluous and meaningless.
Profile
Liu Tianyu: Male, 58 years old, famous detective, strong and medium-sized, owner of Minghao Villa
Li Jingyu: Male, 28 years old, lawyer, medium build, passionate about charity, the only son of the richest man in the world.
Yu Zebei: Male, 24 years old, new police detective, thin, greedy and weak character, one of Liu Tianyu’s adopted sons
Fan Tingwei: Male, 24 years old, carrying bricks at the construction site, tall and strong, with a domineering personality, one of Liu Tianyu's adopted sons
Yang Ke: Female, 22 years old, bank clerk, pretty, tall, from a poor family
Wu Kun: Male, 65 years old, housekeeper of the villa, tall and thin, but somewhat hunched due to old age, he does not look tall. He is loyal and honest.
On a hot summer night, there was finally a bit of coolness in the evening breeze. Two people, one tall and one short, were chatting and eating while walking around the lake.
Suddenly, the tall man stopped and asked as if thoughtfully: "Old Han, tell me, is there really a perfect crime in this world?"
"Of course it's impossible," another person said without hesitation. "The legal net is very tight. As long as it is a crime, there will definitely be clues left. No matter how superb and exquisite the design is, there will always be a day when it is discovered. So this There is no such thing as a perfect crime."
The man called Lao Han said so much in one breath, and he obviously believed in his words. After all, he himself is a reasoning enthusiast, and the existence of such a thing as a "perfect crime" is a stain on him. and humiliation.
"That's it...Then what I say next may subvert your understanding..."
The tall man suddenly smiled and talked about the tragedy that happened at Minghao Villa.